top of page

Bootstrapping Ex Nihilo: Prospective Luthier needs Tardis

squilley0
Oct 25
12 min read

What I really need is a time-machine. I could then jump ahead 3 years and take stock. Knowing what I will know then, I could come back and adjust my plans and purchases in the present and maybe stop wasting so much time and money.  In the absence of such a machine, I have become a tool auction addict, buying stuff that may work, that I might need and that I may even end up using – assuming this whole woodworker-skills-tools-time-motivation ecosystem comes together.


And it is a system. Assembling the parts without really understanding the whole is something like trying to reconstruct the Beatle's Sgt. Pepper's album from only the animated description of two rock music nerds, after 8 pints and two packs of Marlborough Lights in the Cooperage on Newcastle Quayside on a friday night. Even with air guitar, air violin and air piano and brown ale bottle trumpet, they really would be pushed to communicate anything more than 'mind blowing' or [insert from random rock critic hyperbole generator]

I’m facing the classic evolutionary conundrum – what Richard Dawkins referred to as Mount Improbable: the evolutionary challenge of reaching a higher peak of biological perfection without ever taking a "step down" in survival fitness (the 'up' and 'down' coming from a gravitational 'state space' metaphor that biologists are fond of). Because natural selection only permits immediate, advantageous 'steps up,' a species can become trapped on a lower peak, unable to cross the valley of less-fit genetic mutations required to reach a superior summit. Evolving a complex organ like an eye is, Dawkins argued, improbable -- at least a first sight (no pun intended) -- because it's hard to imagine a utility for half an eye (i.e. all the intermediate steps necessary to get to a fully functioning eye).


It turns out that in evolution there is always an ascending path between the two peaks. In the domain of craft culture, I'm not quite so lucky. I need the whole system in order to become a luthier and build a guitar. But each individual component depends on the existence of all the others to make any kind of sense. There is no universe in which the myriad prerequisite steps and sometimes dubious investments that are needed for this artisanal system are going to be useful incrementally, in and of themselves. A chisel by itself will just sit on the shelf. It needs to be sharpened. It requires a bench and a vise – and can only really be used in association with a whole raft of other tools. And of course, it’s only really useful once the requisite skills are developed – in the first instance, the knowledge, hand-eye coordination and know-how necessary to sharpen it. But even to sharpen the chisel requires mundane choices born of experience that I don’t have: e.g. which sharpening stone or strop to purchase; or whether to get a bench-top sharpening machine, or perhaps a sharpening angle jig.


So human culture can't leverage evolutionary dynamics -- at least not in my shed. Who knew? But then what did I expect? This IS the learning curve – and especially for a mid-life exercise in creatio ex nihilo. The ‘time machine’  accessed by traditional craftsmen was creatio in societate which is to say they picked it up, on the job, from people around them. The learning trajectory was a function of familial, generational experience: a lifetime of working for, with, alongside and over other people: father, brother, mother, sister, granny, grandpa, master, journey man, apprentice, competitor or collaborator.


Unfortunately, I’m not dipping into a generational stream of experience nor an inherited reservoir of skills, tools, techniques. It’s just me. But I do have YouTube.


I will come back to that.


The space:


So, I have set about constructing a workshop in a small, single garage. The very first thing I should acknowledge is that I’m very lucky to have such a space. This is a very big plus. I don’t have to fight my wife for the basement which is currently housing about 4000 vintage sweaters and textiles collected from Value Village for future repurposing. She is inside. I am outside. This is, I am told, a healthy arrangement. And having any dedicated space is a big plus. Thankyou God.


A few years ago, my friend Aaron and I took out the large swinging garage door, framed the gaping hole and added a couple of recycled windows. We insulated and drywalled leaving the resulting workshop with only a side-door.  On a whim, we also put in a salvaged, sliding glass door to the rear. This was perhaps a mistake. At the time I didn’t have any inkling of iron law of small workshops:  namely husband your wall space jealously (do people still use ‘husband’ like that?) 


Anyway, I set about building some very rough working surfaces and cupboards and the result is functional – I guess – if not pretty. Honestly though, it’s pretty shoddy. I used whatever wood I had around, and as usual the aesthetic is brutalist functionality. Assuming I ever manage to build more than one guitar, I would be ashamed to show any potential customer my artisan-cave because it screams all sorts of things – but ‘attention to detail is not one of them’!





Some of this is not my fault. The garage faces up the sloping drive and provides the first obstacle for run-off that sheds off the road like a mountain stream. In the winter, the prevailing wind dumps 3-4 feet of snow in enormous drifts which then periodically melts. Keeping water out has been a challenge.

To add to the unprofessional indignity, the floor of the garage also slopes, and the sides are not square. This has given all of my amateur workshop shelves a predictably drunken look. The rolling bench I constructed, looks fine until it is resting in its place against the wall.  The chisel storage shelves which are level. The bench inclines with the floor.  Put it this way, I don’t think I will be modelling for the Lee Valley house magazine any time soon.



The problem of temperament


This is partly a personality thing. My temperament is all about results. Playing football as a kid, I was always a Wimbledon style ‘route one’ kind of player: terrible ball skills and focused not on the process – the unfolding ballet of the beautiful game—but on getting the ball in the box and beating, hustling and bustling it over the line in any way possible.


I can see that in trying to turn myself into a craftsman I am going to be fighting my genes, my schooling and half a lifetime of bad habits. Mainly I’m going to have to force myself to learn to enjoy the process; to savour each step. I really don’t know if this will be possible. I have given up booze for 2 months, but I haven’t managed to lose weight. Ok, it’s not like I am Jacob wrestling with God, but contending with a highly congealed personality, and patterns of behaviour and psychology locked in over decades – this is going to be a tall order. And in all seriousness, I think this might be the most difficult aspect of the craftsman metamorphosis that I’m seeking. The inner transformation.

‘Paint the fence’.



The workshop

Ok – back to the workshop. I started to collect a bunch of tools. Some of these are big basic power tools that I assumed I would need (see below for a full list with some photos). I also got basic hand tools that I imagined would be necessary. To this end I consulted a whole series of guides and tools online as well as a bunch of books. This guide from The Art of Lutherie has proved particularly useful – and expensive.


A lot of this stuff came from auctions – and along the way, somewhat predictably, as well as some bargains, I wasted a lot of money. The SouthBend lathe was clearly an insane flight of fancy. I'm determined to keep it because I want to have a go making some Northumbrian Pipes at some point. But honestly, this was a case of being auction trigger happy and not then having given up the booze. It won't happen again. I promise.



The 1960s Beaver table saw was free, although I paid 50 quid for the rolling stand. It also came with a small jointer. But I realized almost immediately that it took up masses of space and was almost useless. In my small workshop, I have almost no room for manoeuvre and I can’t roll it out into any space big enough to do the most basic things – like cutting up an 8x4 ¾ inch plywood sheet to make a miter table and other jigs and bits and pieces for the shop. So, it has to go! This is assuming that I can get it out of the narrow side door. Down the road, I will have to find a portable onsite job saw. More money.


Other things like this Delta bandsaw were very sound bargains. I was very chuffed with this number and I think it will do me very well




The rotating miter saw.


One of the most impressive blokey power-tools I did buy was a Dewalt sliding miter saw. Because of that ‘Tardis problem’ of not quite knowing what I will need and why, and because I am a bloke, I got the highest spec model that I couldn’t afford. It is big and it is heavy. It takes up a lot of space. And not having a coterie of craftsmen colleagues or a tooled-up know-how uncle to consult, I did what everyone does now which is to consult the online repository which is YouTube. And what I found on every woodwork and amateur luthier channel were segments discussing the problem of space and advocating a whole range of clever space-saving ‘solutions’.  For instance – the ‘French Cleat’ system for efficient wall space: These 10 French Cleat Designs Will Inspire Your Next Build’ from the Evening Woodworker.


Who knew? But one such solution came up all the time and caught my eye. There are literally hundreds of designs for ‘rotating’ tool tables which allow big power tools to be stowed away, or doubled up to provide an extra worktop when the tool is not in use, or two unwieldy tools crammed into a single unit. Things like this beauty


 

This was good. This was something I figured I could do. So, I pulled up PowerPoint and started designing my own version. I spent hours trying to manipulate all the variables to make it work – getting completely lost in myriad different variants.


 

I managed to get two heavy duty bearings on Kijiji for 15 quid (dollars, bucks ... can Canadians say ‘quid’) and a length of 1- inch round steel bar from the local metal merchant and I set about building the thing.


And I was immediately confronted by the climbing ‘mount improbable’ whole/part problem. This is recognized more colloquially in the image of someone pulling themselves up by their own bootstraps.  

The competent hairy guys on YouTube were building their workshop furniture with skills and habits already acquired, in well-equipped workshops with plenty of space and using premium ¾ plywood. My first problem was that bloody ½ ton beaver table saw. There was physically no space to rip the plywood inside the shop. Which meant I was working on the garage floor with a circular saw. And where they had 36-inch shop squares, I had a only a measuring tape and a piece of 2x4 to use as a straight edge.


And of course, in construction, measuring and cutting errors, however small, compound each other. With a sheet of plywood, you have the outside edges that are in principle straight. But once you are using your own cuts as a measuring baseline – cuts done with a circular saw and a shaky inexperienced hand – the potential for cascading errors begins to grow exponentially.


And then of course I experienced things the Youtubers never experienced. My 1-inch steel bar didn’t slide easily over the bearing. I had to go to work with a mallet, and then a hammer and eventually a grinder. In the end I did manage to build the table, I got it into the workshop. I even remembered that final assembly would have to come once inside- because of that narrow door. But those cascading bodges and the need to ‘make it work’ mean that the end result has a family resemblance to my ‘hedgehog roof rack’ more than the polished pieces of workshop cabinetry produced by the slick Worshipful Company of 21st century YouTube Crafters.


This whole process was shaping up as usual to be ugly but functional. It works. But I really, hope that the guitar I build is just a little more beautiful.



Analysis: The Bootstrapping Problem


I’m running out of space before I have started. I have blown the budget trying to create a functioning minimum toolset, without knowing exactly what I would need. I am buying tools without necessarily understanding too much about what they do. And I’m fighting my own personality which tends towards hasty, impatient functionality. 


Disregarding my own shortcomings, I have repeatedly run up against what I call the bootstrapping problem. The creation of each ‘part’ is dependent on the existence of a functioning ‘whole’ – in this case, knowledge, basic skills, a clear idea of the direction in which I am headed, a reasonable anticipation of any obstacles and future requirements (especially vis space) and a functioning ecosystem of tools.


Creatio ex Nihilo


A few years ago, I invited UK space scientist Lewis Dartnell to the University of Waterloo to talk about his book The Knowledge: How to Rebuild Our World from Scratch.  If modern civilization collapsed, he asked, what essential knowledge would survivors need to rebuild it? Rather than simply cataloguing technologies, Dartnell showed how civilization is a layered system of dependencies, beginning with agriculture, sanitation, metallurgy, and energy before progressing to more advanced technologies.

In a more whimsical vein, Thomas Thwaites's The Toaster Project attempted to build an ordinary electric toaster starting from raw materials he gathered himself, mining iron and copper ores, extracting materials, and even trying to make plastic from crude oil. After months of effort, extensive travel, and considerable "cheating" through the use of modern knowledge and infrastructure, he produced a crude functioning toaster that cost vastly more than a store-bought model.



The project dramatically illustrated a key theme shared with Dartnell: the technologies we take for granted embody the accumulated expertise, supply chains, and cooperation of an entire civilization, making even a simple toaster effectively impossible for one person to reproduce from scratch.


Together, Dartnell and Thwaites reveal how profoundly dependent modern life is on collective cultural knowledge. Making a toaster from scratch is rather extreme example. But in attempting to jump-start a fully functioning luthier workshop, I have been bumping into a more quotidian version of the same problem.


There is a fantastic podcast called OMO which deals with the lives of violin makers. In their first episode they recount the story of Omobono Stradivari or  ‘Omo’ from whom the podcast takes its name.  Omo was not the celebrated master. He was the son who didn’t inherit the workshop and the name. But although now synonymous with a kind of failure, Omo was in fact  a very competent luthier immersed in all of the requisite skills and habits of mind.


Omo has been treated unfairly by history partly because modern narratives are obsessed with the heroic individual designer and craft-entrepreneur. Working in early modern Italy, the Stradivari family bridged the very different lifeworlds of medieval and modern craftsmanship.   The contrast between the modern aspiring luthier and Omo perfectly illustrates the problem I am encountering.  It also explicates two very different ways of acquiring human skill and knowledge.


A modern beginner, such as I, necessarily approaches lutherie as an autonomous individual. Starting from scratch, I gather information from books, YouTube videos, plans, online forums, and technical manuals. The underlying assumption is that sufficient information, rational analysis, and deliberate effort can produce mastery. Knowledge is treated primarily as something explicit: facts, techniques, measurements, and procedures that can be transmitted from one mind to another.


Omo represents a very different world. He did not learn violin making by seeking out information. He was born into a workshop and into a lineage of practice. From childhood he would have absorbed the sights, sounds, routines, and judgments of the craft. He learned not merely by instruction but by participation. The workshop itself functioned as a repository of accumulated experience that far exceeded what any single individual could fully articulate.


Rarely if ever would anyone seek to set up an artisan workshop from scratch whilst simultaneously acquiring the concomitant craft skills. This simply didn’t happen. The fact of intergenerational continuity is testified by hundreds of European surnames – Wrightson, Cooperson etc. In this premodern setting, skill was transmitted through immersion within an intergenerational stream. Knowledge was embodied as much as verbalized. The apprentice absorbed habits of perception and judgment long before being able to explain them. The craft was carried by families, workshops, guilds, and local communities whose shared experience stretched across generations.


Many of the most important elements of expert craftsmanship cannot easily be reduced to written instructions. The feel of a sharp edge, the response of a piece of spruce under a plane, the visual sense that an arching is correct, or the subtle judgement required when fitting components are forms of tacit knowledge acquired through long exposure and repetition. These capacities are often difficult for masters themselves to explain fully.


The irony is that even a relatively ordinary member of a great craft lineage may possess forms of practical knowledge that are unavailable to a highly intelligent outsider beginning from first principles. The workshop accumulates insights, techniques, and habits over decades and generations. Individuals inherit this cultural capital without necessarily being conscious of all that they have received.


The contrast, therefore, is not merely between two people but between two conceptions of human achievement. The modern hobbyist embodies the ideal of the self-directed individual pursuing mastery through explicit knowledge and rational effort – the ideal projected back onto Stradivari senior and his chosen heir Francesco. Although missing out on time-honored celebrity, the younger son Omo was still a skilled craftsman and embodied a world in which skill emerges from continuity, tradition, apprenticeship, family, and community. In that world, the true bearer of knowledge is not simply the individual craftsman but the lineage and culture of practice that sustain the craft across generations.

 

 

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page